The
American Academy of Financial Management Journal
Volume
6 - Spring 2005
International
Assigned ISBN(0-9749946-0-X)The
American Academy of Financial Management Journal
College
Savings Plans, Financial Aid, and Tax Strategy
Dean Richard Whiteside, PhD and Prof. George S. Mentz,
JD, MBA, MFP ™ Master Financial Professional
For
years, the annual rate of increase in the cost of a
year of study at a college or university has outpaced
the rate of inflation. Today the cost of earning a college
degree has promoted the college purchase into second
place, after a home, on the list of most expensive purchases
made by American families. For some families, the cost
of the college purchase may exceed even the cost of
their home purchase!
The
College Board reported that the average annual cost
for one year of study, living at home, at a four-year
publicly supported institution was $13,463 for academic
year 2002-03. The annual average cost of attending a
private college or university during 2002-03 amounted
to $27,667. If the annual rate of increase in these
costs averages 5% in the future, the cost of a baccalaureate
degree for a child entering the first grade in September
2003 will reach approximately $104,000 at a public institution
and just over $214,000 at a private institution. The
financial burden on families with more than one child
is, and will continue to be, enormous. Today's parents
of young children are left wondering, will we be able
to send our children to college?
Concern
over the cost of a college education isn't new. Each
generation of parents has wrestled with the problem.
While today's costs are higher than ever before, parents
of prospective college-bound students now have many
more options at their disposal for dealing with these
costs. In fact, the sheer number of options and the
complexity of some of them has given rise to a whole
new field of financial planning - financial planning
for college costs. Five key questions drive the financial
planning for college.
1.
How much financial aid will be available?
2. Will we be eligible for need-based financial aid?
3. How much will we pay from annual income?
4. How much will we pay from savings?
5. How much will we finance?
Since
the answer to any one of these questions effects the
answer to the remaining questions, any discussion of
college finance must focus on these five questions as
a group. The information needed to create a financing
plan suitable for a particular family is extensive but
it can be categorized into broad categories for the
purposes of gaining a basic understanding of the available
options. For the purposes of clarity, the following
categories will be discussed.
1.
Financial aid programs
2. Tax relief provisions for families experiencing educational
expenditures
3. Tax incentives for those wishing to save for educational
expenses
These
categories are analyzed as they relate to the Financial
Aid Process model shown in the Illustration 1.
Financial Aid Programs
Creating
an effective strategy for financing a college education
requires some basic knowledge of the financial aid programs
and processes currently in place. While financial aid
rules and regulations are numerous and complex, families
trying to formulate a college investment strategy only
need to understand the basic principles of the process.
Two types of financial aid are available: need-based
financial assistance and merit-based financial assistance.
Merit-based
financial aid awards recognize the student's special
skills or academic achievement. In making these awards,
institutions do not consider whether or not the funds
are needed by the student. The only consideration is
the individual's special abilities or achievements.
Need-based financial aid involves an analysis of the
family's ability to pay for college with financial aid
being awarded to cover the portion of the cost of college
that exceeds the family's capability. This assessment
of "need" involves the consideration of a
number of factors including the cost of a particular
college, the family's income and the family's assets.
Financial
assistance can come in the form of grants, scholarships,
loans or work-study arrangements. Grants and scholarships
represent a real reduction in the cost of attending
the institution and carry no obligations for repayment.
Educational loans come in many forms but they all share
the requirement that the amount borrowed plus interest
must eventually be repaid. Work-based financial assistance
comes in the form of an hourly wage for services performed.
The
funds for these programs come from a variety of sources
including the federal and state governments, the colleges
themselves, private organizations and scholarship foundations.
Funds from state or federal or state sources are administered
in strict compliance with the rules and regulations
established by the federal government and the state
providing the assistance. In the case of funds from
the federal government, the rules and regulations apply
uniformly to all residents of the United States. Individual
states are free to establish their own rules and regulations
for financial aid funded from state sources. Private
organizations, individuals and colleges are free to
establish their own rules and regulations for the administration
of the funds they provide. As a result, a particular
college student may have to comply with several sets
of financial aid rules and regulations. Although there
are differences in these sets of regulations, they have
many commonalities - particularly in the areas of calculating
cost, determination of what a family can contribute
and the calculation of financial need.
The
real cost of attending a college includes what must
be paid for tuition, student fees, living expenses,
books, transportation to and from the school and miscellaneous
personal expenses. The total of these for a particular
college is called its "annual cost of attendance."
The living expenses for students choosing to live on-campus
are represented by the charges the college makes for
room and board. The families of students living at home
do not experience the college's room and board charges
but they do experience a real cost in providing housing
and meals for their college age children. The annual
cost of attendance budget recognizes these costs by
using a "home maintenance allowance" - an
estimation of these costs - as an item in the student
cost of attendance budget. Tuition, fees, room and board
are paid directly to the college and represent a direct
expense. The cost of books, transportation, home maintenance
and miscellaneous expenses are paid as incurred by the
family and represent indirect or out-of-pocket expenses.
Regardless of whether the expense is a direct or indirect
expense it is still part of the real cost of going to
college and is therefore used in determining the student's
annual budget.
Current
public policy defines college attendance as a voluntary
activity. Unlike the elementary and secondary educational
opportunities that are provided on a cost free basis
to every U.S. resident, the costs associated with attending
college, although subsidized heavily by state and local
governments, remains an obligation of the student and
their family. To make attendance possible, financial
aid is provided to help the family cover the portion
of the cost of attendance that exceeds the family's
resources. This system requires that some method be
employed to determine what a particular family can afford
to pay for college. This is called the family contribution
and includes both what the parent and the student can
contribute toward the cost of attending.
The
United States Congress has developed a methodology for
determining the expected family contribution for those
students desiring to receive federally funded financial
aid. This approach - the Federal Methodology - is also
used by many states in the administration of the programs
that they sponsor. The Federal Methodology is the only
method that can be used in determining eligibility for
federally funded financial aid programs. In the administration
of financial aid funded by individual colleges or private
parties, those providing these funds may require additional
information not considered in the Federal Methodology.
As a result, some colleges also employ an "Institutional
Methodology" in the determination of ability to
pay. These institutionally specific methodologies can
be used only in the administration of the funds that
come directly from their own resources. An Institutional
Methodology can never be used in place of the Federal
Methodology for determining eligibility for federally
funded financial aid programs.
In
the Federal Methodology the parents' and student's earning
and assets are analyzed to determine the amount the
family can contribute toward the student's educational
expenses. Families in stronger financial positions are
expected to contribute more than families with lower
incomes and fewer assets. It is difficult to provide
an estimate of the expected contribution based on income
because the formula treats income and assets separately
and because the formula allows families to take "deductions"
that vary by family size, the state of residence, total
taxes paid and the age of the older parent. Illustration
2 provides a very rough estimate of the expected contribution
based on family income. For the purposes of Illustration
2 family assets have been excluded.
Illustration 2
Expected
Family Contribution
Based on Parent Income
Family
of 4
One In College
Older Parent is 48 Years Old
Income
Estimated Contribution Income Estimated Contribution
$10,000 0 $75,000 $9,701
$15,000 0 $80,000 $11,096
$20,000 0 $85,000 $12,491
$25,000 0 $90,000 $13,973
$30,000 $80 $95,000 $15,513
$35,000 $876 $100,000 $17,054
$40,000 $1,672 $105,000 $18,594
$45,000 $2,467 $110,000 $20,134
$50,000 $3,342 $115,000 $21,675
$55,000 $4,369 $120,000 $23,215
$60,000 $5,652 $125,000 $24,717
$65,000 $6,912 $130,000 $26,187
$70,000 $8,306 $135,000 $27,657
The family contribution is considered available to offset
educational expenses. If there is only one child in
college the entire family contribution is considered
to be available for the use of that student. However,
if more than one child is in college at any given time,
the contribution is divided equally among the students
in college. Thus, if three children from the same family
are in college at the same time, the contribution for
each child is one-third of the total family contribution.
Many
families are shocked by the amount of the family contribution.
When the contribution is added to their fixed obligations
for housing, cars and other goods and services they
often conclude that providing the amount specified on
an annual basis will be impossible. In today's economy,
the family contribution is really an index of the family's
financial strength. The correct interpretation of family
contribution is that the amount represents the amount
that the family can absorb, given its current situation,
in terms of cash payments or borrowing. Most American
families will come to realize that a college education
is a financed purchase similar to the purchase of a
home or car although the item purchased is far less
tangible.
Financial
need is defined as the difference between the cost of
attendance at a particular college and the family contribution.
Because of the wide variation in the cost of attendance
at different types of institutions, student need varies
widely. Although cost varies from one institution to
another, the family contribution remains constant. As
a result, a student may have no need at one institution
but demonstrate considerable need at another. For example,
if the family contribution is calculated to be $15,000
and the student attends a college with a cost of attendance
of $15,000, the student's need would be zero. However,
if the same student selected a college with a $35,000
annual cost of attendance the student would have $20,000
in need.
The
objective of need-based financial aid programs is to
provide the student with access to the funds needed
to meet demonstrated need. In the best of all worlds,
the institution would be able to provide the student
with all of the funds needed to meet this need. In reality
however, many institutions do not have access to sufficient
resources to meet the needs of all students seeking
to enroll. When this is the case, the sum of the family
contribution and the financial aid offered by the college
may amount to less than the cost of attendance. In these
cases there is a "gap" between available resources
and cost. Such gaps make attending that college more
difficult.
A
family can calculate its own expected family contribution
by using various financial aid calculators that are
available on the Internet. One of the most popular and
useful websites for financial aid information can be
found at: http://www.finaid.org/. This comprehensive
financial aid site provides a wealth of information
about scholarships, educational loans, college savings
plans and a series of "calculators" that allow
families to estimate their family contribution, loan
repayment obligations, etc.
Tax Relief For Families With Educational Expenses
Federal
tax law changes that took place in 1997 and again in
2003 provide tax relief for families with children in
college. These mechanisms are most useful to families
with students currently enrolled in colleges or to those
families with little time left to save for college.
The tax changes that took effect in 1997 and 2003 also
included provisions intended to motivate families to
save for college. The savings options and benefits are
detailed in a subsequent section. In this section only
the tax relief programs are examined.
The
various tax relief programs are describe briefly.
Hope
Credits
In 1997, the $1,500 HOPE program was created to make
the first two years of college universally available
to all American families. For students in the first
two years of college taxpayers can claim a tax credit
equal to 100% of the first $1,000 of tuition and fees
and 50% of the second $1,000. These amounts are indexed
for inflation after 2001.
The
credit is available on a per-student basis for net tuition
and fees (tuition and fees less the amount of financial
aid received that is in the form of grants or scholarships)
paid for college enrollment after December 31, 1997.
For 2003, the credit is phased out for joint filers
with between $83,000 and $103,000 of income, and for
single filers with incomes between $41,000 and $51,000
(indexed periodically). The credit can be claimed in
two tax years for any individual enrolled on at least
a half-time basis for any portion of the year.
Lifetime Learning Credits
In 1997, Congress created the Lifetime Learning Credit
for College Juniors, Seniors, Graduate Students and
working Americans pursuing lifelong learning to upgrade
their skills. For those beyond the first two years of
college, or taking classes part-time to improve or upgrade
their job skills, the family will receive a 20% tax
credit for the first 10,000 of expenses. The credit
is available for net tuition and fees (less grant aid)
paid for post-secondary enrollment. The credit is available
on a per-taxpayer (family) basis, and is phased out
at the same income levels as the HOPE tax credits. Note
- there can only be one credit taken per child, either
Hope of Lifetime Learning but not both.
Student
Loan Interest Deduction
The Student Loan Interest Deduction provisions of the
1997 tax law changes allows for an "above-the-line
deduction" (the taxpayer does not need to itemize
in order to benefit) for interest paid in the repayment
on private or government-backed loans used for post-secondary
education and training expenses. The maximum deduction
is $2,500. It is phased out for joint filers with incomes
between $100,000 and $130,000, and for single filers
with incomes between $50,000 and $65,000 (indexed after
2002). The deduction is available for loans made before
or after enactment of the tax change. The loan amount
eligible for the deduction is limited to post-secondary
expenses for tuition, fees, books, equipment, room,
and board, and this tax break has been extended beyond
the original application to the first 5 years of repayment.
IRA
Withdrawals.
Taxpayers may withdraw funds from an IRA, without penalty,
for the higher education expenses of the taxpayer, spouse,
child, or grandchild. The amount that can be withdrawn
without penalty is limited to net post-secondary expenses
(expenses less other forms of grant or scholarship financial
aid) for tuition, fees, books, equipment, and room and
board.
Community
Service Loan Forgiveness
This provision excludes from taxable income loan amounts
forgiven by non-profit, tax-exempt charitable or educational
institutions for borrowers who take community-service
jobs addressing unmet needs.
Saving For College
In
addition to providing tax relief, the recent tax code
changes also created several college savings mechanisms
that receive favorable tax treatment. These provisions
should be of particular interest to those families who
have several years or more before their children begin
to enroll in college.
One
of the key questions in formulating a college savings
plan relates to the issue of whom - the parent or the
student- controls the savings account. In other words,
to who does the money really belong. Since savings accounts
typically generate interest and such interest may be
taxed, many families decide to place the savings in
the student's name under the assumption that the student
normally is usually in a lower tax bracket than the
parents. The second concern expressed by families revolves
around the question: if we do save won't these savings
reduce our son or daughter's eligibility for financial
aid?
In
the vast majority of cases, it is in the long-term interest
of the parents to maintain control over the savings
earmarked for college even though some of the interest
earned may trigger increased income tax liability. The
existing needs analysis formulas provide a relatively
favorable treatment of parental savings when compared
with the treatment of student savings. In constructing
the needs analysis formula, Congress recognized the
simple fact that parents should be saving "for
their own future - for their retirement." As a
result, two provisions were established that impact
how parental assets are used in the determination of
family contribution. The first provision establishes
an "asset protection allowance" that is determined
by the age of the older parent. The amount of the allowance
is deducted from the total asset value thereby reducing
the overall value of the asset for needs analysis purposes.
The second provision involves the percentage of the
remaining asset balance that enters into the family's
adjusted income. Currently this percentage is set at
12% of the remaining asset balance. The 12% value is
then added to the family's adjusted income. The total
adjusted income is then "taxed" using a sliding
scale depending upon the level of adjusted income. The
highest marginal rate for parents is currently 37% excluding
state and non-federal taxation.
Student
assets are treated more harshly in the needs analysis
formula. Congress determined that the primary focus
of college-age students should be on completing their
education, not providing for their long-term retirement
needs. As a result, there is no asset protection allowance
provision for student assets. Furthermore, the percentage
of the student controlled asset considered available
to underwrite the annual cost of attendance is set at
a flat 35% rate. Illustration 4 demonstrates how these
provisions impact eligibility for financial aid for
a family with no assets, a family with $100,000 in assts
held in the parents' names and a family with $100,000
in assets held in the student's name. The table is constructed
for families with identical incomes attending the same
institution.
As
detailed in the illustration, the asset held in the
parent's name retains approximately 96% of its initial
value (assuming a 2% annual interest on the principal)
after four years of deductions for college expenses.
When the asset is in the student's name less than 20%
of the original value remains in tact. Since many financial
aid packages will also include student loans, families
with considerable assets are in a position to reduce
reliance on loans by choosing to utilize a larger percentage
of the asset value than is required by the Federal Methodology.
This incremental use of assets can reduce the family's
reliance on student loans that will likely be a part
of the student's financial aid package.
Many
families underestimate the power of long-term savings.
Even modest monthly savings beginning when a child is
born can create a sizeable asset to cover college related
expenses. Illustration 3 shows the accumulated value
of family savings for a newborn child (18 years of savings
prior to college entry) for interest rates between 2
and 5% annually for monthly savings of between $50.00
per month and $700 per month. This analysis assumes
that the savings are in a tax-free investment vehicle
and that the monthly payment occurs on the first of
each month.
Illustration 3
Savings
Calculator
Annual Interest Paid On Account
Amount Monthly 2% 3% 4% 5%
$50 $13,009 $14,333 $15,832 $17,533
$100 $26,017 $28,666 $31,664 $35,062
$200 $52.035 $57,331 $63,329 $70,131
$300 $78,052 $85,997 $94,993 $105,197
$400 $104,069 $114,622 $126,658 $140,263
$500 $130,086 $143,328 $158,322 $175,329
$600 $156,014 $171,993 $189,987 $210,394
$700 $182,121 $200,659 $221,651 $245,460
Illustration 4
Impact of Asset Value on Financial Aid Eligibility
No Assets $100,000 Parental Asset $100,000 Student Asset
Institution's Cost of Attendance $25,000 $25,000 $25,000
Family income $75,000 $75,000 $75,000
Contribution from income $9,701 $9,701 $9,701
Assets $0 $100,000 $100,000
Asset protection allowance N/A $44,400 $0
Adjusted asset value N/A $55,600 $100,000
% of asset used to supplement income N/A 12% 35%
Amount of asset available as a supplement to income
N/A $6,672 $35,000
Amount of supplement added to family contribution at
47% of supplement N/A $3,136 N/A
Total family contribution $9,701 $12,837 $44,701
Remaining need (cost less family contribution) $15,299
$12,163 ($19,701)
Asset value remaining after 4 years assuming no interest
growth * N/A $95,868 $19,322
% of asset remaining post college 95.87% 19.32%
.
* Analysis of Asset Depletion: Parent versus Student
Asset
Parent Asset
Student's Year In College 1 2 3 4
Age of Older Parent 48 49 50 51
Asset Beginning Balance $100,000 $98,801 $97,711 $96,731
Annual Interest 2% 2% 2% 2%
Asset Protection Allowance $44,400 $45,500 $46,700 $48,100
Adjusted Net Worth $55,600 $53,301 $51,011 $48,631
Conversion at 12% $6,672 $6,396 $6,121 $5,836
Taxation Rate at 47% $3,136 $3,006 $2,877 $2,743
Revised Asset Value $96,864 $95,795 $94,834 $93,988
Plus 2% Interest $98,801 $97,711 $96,731 $95,868
Percent of Asset Remaining 95.87%
Total Cash Expenditure From Asset $11,762
Student Asset
Student's Year In College 1 2 3 4
Asset Beginning Balance $100,000 $66,300 $43,957 $29,143
Taxation Rate 35% 35% 35% 35%
Used For educational Expenses $35,000 $23,205 $15,385
$10,200
Remaining Asset $65,000 $43,095 $28,572 $18,943
Pus 2% Interest $1,300 $862 $571 $379
End of Year Asset Balance $66,300 $43,957 $29,143 $19,322
Percent of Asset Remaining 66.30% 43.96% 29.14% 19.32%
Total Cash Expenditure $83,790
Given
the existing needs analysis methodology, the only time
placing the money in the student's name makes sense
is when the parents are certain that their financial
situation is such that there is no way that the family
will qualify for financial aid - even at America's most
expensive college and universities or if there are estate
planning considerations. In these situations a transfer
of funds to the student may be beneficial from the parents'
tax standpoint.
Estate Planning, Gifts, and Control
Unless you are wealthy (individual assets over $1 million
adjusted periodically for inflation), maintaining custody
of the accounts holding the funds for a child's educational
expenses should not affect your estate plan. Two types
of accounts generally are at issue: interest bearing
savings accounts or investment accounts in the name
of the child where a parent, guardian or third party
is the owner or custodian over the account until the
child goes to college. The value of any account over
which you have custody is reflected in your estate,
if you name yourself custodian and you die while the
child is a minor.
If
you and your spouse are worth over $1 million individually
or cumulatively, you may need to evaluate how you invest
for a child or grandchild's education. Unfortunately,
the only way to reduce estate taxes is to reduce the
size of your estate. One of the most effective ways
to accomplish that goal is through gifts. You can presently
give up to $11,000 ($22,000 with your spouse) per year
to each of your children tax free. In a sizeable estate
taxed at 49%, that $22,000 in inheritance would be reduced
to just $11,220. Such annual gifts can be especially
valuable (and significant in reducing estate taxes)
when they consist of appreciating assets. You can also
give more than this amount annually, but the gift(s)
will count against your Unified Tax Credit. However,
you can pay college tuition directly to an institution
on behalf of a student without incurring gift taxes.
What are Custody Accounts: Advantages and Disadvantages
If your children are young or if you prefer that they
not have control of cash, you may want to consider establishing
a custodial account under the Uniform Gifts to Minors
Act (UGMA) or the Uniform Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA).
Under these provisions, gifts and investment earnings
can accumulate under your supervision as custodian.
As a note, state laws affect this type of account, and
your child may have rights to these investments at age
eighteen or twenty one (age of majority). Keep in mind
that the kiddie tax laws may apply here and unearned
income may be subject to the parents tax rate until
age 14.
529
Plans (Section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code)
A 529 is an investment plan operated by individual states
that are designed to help families save for future college
costs. As long as the 529 Plan meets basic requirements,
the federal tax law provides special tax benefits to
you.
Each
state now has at least one 529 Plan available. Section
529 of the IRS code provides for the establishment of
two types of college financing instruments: either prepaid
tuition or college savings plans. (Some states offer
both options.) Some states offering prepaid tuition
contracts covering in-state tuition may allow you to
transfer the value of your contract to private and out-of-state
schools. However, you may not receive full value in
these kinds of transfers. If you use a 529 savings program,
the full value of your account can be used at any accredited
college or university in the country (and even some
foreign institutions). Both types of 529 financing plans
are funded through "after tax dollars." See
Illustration 7 for a summary of the 529 Plans sponsored
by each state.
A
529 plan investment grows tax-free for as long as your
money is within the plan. When you allow a distribution
to pay for the beneficiary's college costs, the distribution
is federal tax-free as well. This applies for distributions
in the years 2003 through 2010. Unless Congress extends
this tax code provision, 529 distributions made after
2010 will be taxable to the beneficiary (i.e. only gains
above the principal originally invested).
The
big benefit is that the donor stays in control of the
529 Plan account. With few exceptions, the named beneficiary
has no rights to the funds.
The
U.S. Department of Education maintains that 529 savings
accounts are treated as a parent's asset in determining
eligibility for federal financial aid. Thus, the expected
contribution towards your child's college costs is subject
to the same treatment as are other parental assets -
treatment far more favorable than if the funds are under
the ownership of the student.
Since
individual institutions are free to develop their own
methodology for awarding financial aid funded by the
institution (as opposed to financial aid programs funded
by governmental agencies), some institutions may decide
to treat 529 Plan assets differently when determining
eligibility for institutionally funded financial aid.
529
Prepaid tuition plans have a much greater impact on
financial aid eligibility. Distributions from 529 Prepaid
Tuition Plans reduce financial aid eligibility dollar
for dollar. Thus, if your prepaid tuition contract pays
out $5,000 in tuition benefits this year, the student
will be considered as having $5,000 less need for financial
aid.
Upon
the completion of a beneficiary's education, the balance
in a 529 account reverts to the owner of the 529 account.
This will trigger a tax event on the accumulated earnings
for the account owner.
Details
regarding the 529 plans offered by each state can be
found on the Internet. The most comprehensive sites
can be found at: http://www.savingforcollege.com
and http://www.collegesavings.org.
Coverdell Accounts
What
used to be called the Education IRA (established in
1997) is now titled the Coverdell Education Savings
Account (ESA). In 2002, the contribution limit increased
from $500 per child to $2,000 per child. However, if
accounts that are established by different family members
for the same child cause the total contributions to
exceed $2,000, a penalty may be owed.
The
parents' after tax contribution goes into an account
that will eventually pass to the named child if the
funds are not used for college expenses. Unlike unused
funds in most 529 plans, the donor cannot reclaim these
funds. Since the annual contribution limit is low, the
level of fees and charges to maintain this type of account
should be a major concern when selecting the company
to manage the Coverdell IRA. In general, Coverdell accounts
must be fully withdrawn by the time the beneficiary
reaches age 30, or else it may be subject to tax or
penalties
Funds
in a Coverdell account are considered an asset of the
student, not the parent, for financial aid purposes.
Under the existing federally mandated financial aid
needs analysis system, 35% of a student's assets are
considered additive to the student's contribution from
income. Therefore, if the value of a Coverdell is $20,000,
the impact on the student's eligibility in the first
year of attendance would be $7,000 or 35% of the total
account value. Two notes of interest here are that these
types of accounts may be phased out for singles earning
95-110 thousand and Joint Filers earning 190-220,000
dollars. Moreover, these accounts may be eligible for
used for elementary or secondary expenses.
Conclusion
Although college is more expensive than ever and college
costs are growing at a rate faster than inflation, today's
families have many more options to use in creating a
financial plan for funding the college experience. Creating
the best financial plan for your family means tailoring
the use of these options to your specific needs and
capabilities. This design begins with a clear understanding
of how all of the component parts of the college finance
system function. Illustration 5 provides a graphic representation
of how various savings mechanisms play into the financial
aid process.
Illustration
6 provides a comparative analysis of the different types
of college savings instruments.
The
key elements to evaluate are:
1.
Whether your family will qualify for financial aid
2. If your family will qualify for financial aid, you
probably want to keep the savings asset in the parents'
custody. This strategy will reduce the impact that college
savings will have on financial aid eligibility. Coverdell
and 529 plans allow parents to save for college without
having to pay taxes on the account earnings.
3. If you will not qualify for financial aid, there
may be clear tax advantages to placing the college savings
asset under the student's control. This strategy will
normally reduce parental tax liability. (However, if
the savings are in the form of Coverdell IRAs or a 529
Plan, the interest earned by the custodian (the parent)
is non-taxable.)
4. If exposure to estate taxes is a concern, the Uniform
Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA) or the Uniform Gift to
Minors Act (UGMA) may provide an advantageous option
for reducing estate tax exposure.
5. Even if there is no likely exposure to estate taxation,
families who will not qualify for financial assistance
may experience tax advantages by annual gifts up to
the maximum allowed by law.
*Note
- This document does not claim to give investment, tax
nor legal advice. All tax rules or quoted numbers can
be changed or indexed by the government at any time.
Some phase out salary information in this document may
be based on MAGI or AGI. Moreover, some of these tax
breaks have sunset provision in which they may expire
in a few years. Please consult with a licensed tax,
legal, or investment professional before making any
important decision or any decision related to this document.
Advice herein is subject to the academic exemption for
research. All Rights Reserved 2003
About Prof. Mentz:
Prof. Mentz is first person in the United States to
achieve "Quad Designations" as a JD, MBA,
licensed financial planner, and Certified Financial
Consultant. Mr. Mentz is presently serving as President
and Professor for The American Academy of Financial
Management ™. Mr. Mentz has consulted with Wall Street
Firms, trained hundreds of financial advisors, and instructed
several hundred clients on educational savings, tax
strategy, and estate planning. Mr. Mentz is a Licensed
Attorney and Counselor of Law (LA), and has researched
and published worldwide in the area of taxation, financial
analysis, investments, estate planning, and financial
consulting. Mr. Mentz is presently an adjunct faculty
member for Several Universities teaching online and
on-site, and he has published, written, and presented
multiple articles and research in venues such as print,
magazine, journals, television, college campuses. Mr.
Mentz has prior experience as a Senior Financial Planner
and Wealth Management Advisor for a Wall Street Firm
providing training and research on educational investing.
He holds the MFP™ Master Financial Professional Credential
and the CWM™ Chartered Wealth Manager Credential.
The
Global Journal For International Financial Analysts
(JIFAM) is a scholarly, peer refereed finance journal
that provides a forum and means for exchanging information
on the social impact of information technologies. JIFAM's
scope includes the effects of Financial Management on
business, family, socialization, entertainment, and
education. The Journal publishes original research articles,
short experimental reports, review monographs, technical
notes, as well as special, thematic issues with commentaries.
Types
of manuscripts:
The Finance Journal considers for publication full-length
articles and short-length articles of 1000 to 2000 words.
Short-length articles can generally be published sooner
than full length articles. All material submitted will
be acknowledged on receipt. Full-length articles are
subject to peer review. Copies of the referees' comments
will be forwarded electronically to the author along
with the editor's decision.
Copyright:
No
finance journal article can be published unless accompanied
by a signed publication agreement, which serves as a
transfer of copyright from author to the JIFAM Journal.
A publication agreement may be obtained here. Only original
papers will be accepted and copyright in published papers
will be vested in the publisher. It is the author's
responsibility to obtain written permission to reproduce
material that has appeared in another publication.
Format
of submitted material:
All
manuscripts must be submitted electronically in one
of the following formats: Html, ASCII, RTF Microsoft
Word, Wordperfect. The beginning of the manuscript must
bear the title of the paper and the full names of the
authors as well as their affiliations, full postal and
e-mail addresses. In the case of multiple authors, please
indicate which author is to receive correspondence.
Financial support may be acknowledged within the article
to avoid footnotes. A list of keywords along with an
informative abstract of 200 words or less is required
for full-length articles.
Style:
In
general, the style should follow the forms given in
the Publication Manual of the American Psychological
Association (Washington, DC: 1994).
Organization:
In
general, the background and purpose of the article should
be stated first, followed by details of the methods,
materials, procedures, and equipment used. Findings,
discussion and conclusions should follow in that order.
Appendices are not encouraged. The APA Publication Manual
should be consulted for details as needed.
Figures:
Figures
should be kept to a minimum and be used only when absolutely
necessary. They should be prepared and submitted in
one of the following forms: JPEG File Interchange (jpg),
Compuserve GIF (gif), Windows Bitmaps (bmp), Tagged
Image File (tif), PC Paintbrush (pcx). In any case images
should not exceed width of 450 pixels.
Bibliography:
The
accuracy and completeness of the references is the responsibility
of the author. References to personal letters, paper
presented at meetings, and other unpublished material
may be included. If such material may be of help in
the evaluation of the paper, copies should be made available
to the Editor. Papers which are part of a series should
include a citation of the previous paper. Explanatory
material may be appended to the end of a citation to
avoid footnotes in text. The format for citations in
text for bibliographic references follows the Publication
Manual of the American Psychological Association (4th
ed., 1994). Citation of an author's work in the text
should follow the author-date method of citation; the
surname of the author(s) and the year of publication
should appear in text. For example,
Paisley (1993) found that...
Recent research has shown that...(Schauder, 1994)
In other work (Gordon & Lenk, 1992; Harman, 1991)...
Examples
of citations to a journal article, a book, a chapter
in a book, and published proceedings of a meeting follow:
Buckland, M., & Gey, F. (1994). The relationship
between recall and precision. Journal of the
American Society for Information Science, 45, 12-19.
Borgman, C.L. (Ed.). (1990). Scholarly
communication and bibliometrics. London: Sage.
Bauin, S., & Rothman, H. (1992). "Impact"
of
journals as proxies for citation counts. In P.
Weingart, R. Sehringer, & M. Winterhager (Eds.),
Representations of science and technology (pp.
225-239). Leiden: DSWO Press.
In
case of any question about bibliographic forms, refer
to the Publication Manual of the American Psychological
Association, 4th edition, Washington, DC, 1994. Copies
may be ordered from: APA Order Department, P.O. Box
92984, Washington, DC 20090-2984, USA.
****************************************************
* The Global Journal of International Financial Analysts
(JIFA) *
* IZZZ 1095-139X * 2000
* *
* ANNOUNCEMENT / CALL FOR PAPERS *
****************************************************
The
Global Journal of International Financial Analysts (JIFAM)
is a scholarly, peer refereed journal that provides
a forum and means for exchanging information on the
social impact of information technologies. JIFAM's scope
includes the effects of information technology on business,
socialization, entertainment, and education. The Journal
publishes
original research articles, short experimental reports,
review mono- graphs, technical notes, as well as special,
thematic issues with commentaries.
The
Global Journal of International Financial Analysts (JIFAM)
is unique in providing a diverse forum for those interested
in the effects of theories or implementation of information
technology. It, therefore, promotes an exchange of information
between groups
not always thought to share a common interest. In general,
JIFAM is designed for the following audiences: researchers,
developers, and practitioners in schools, industry,
and government; administrators, policy decision-makers,
and other specialists in computer information systems.
Authors
are invited to submit high quality papers that match
the Journal's scope. The Journal considers for publication
full-length articles and short-length articles of 1000
words or less. Short-length articles can generally be
published sooner than full length articles. All manuscripts
must be submitted electronically. Authors should simply
submit their articles in their standard culturally accepted
form.
ARTICLE
SUBMISSIONS